Butterfly valve vs sluice valve for water mains: Zoloto 1078 vs 1079
Updated 13 Nov 2026 · Reviewed by MTC technical desk
The short answer
On water mains the choice is often a wafer butterfly valve against a flanged sluice valve. In the Zoloto range the butterfly valves 1078 to 1078K run from 40 to 600 mm and the sluice valves 1079A to 1096 from 50 to 600 mm. This guide compares sizes, ratings, marks and prices, and labels the general points as general.
Want prices for these valves? Call 98490 02060 or build a quote list.
The short comparison
The first paragraph below is general engineering knowledge, labelled as such. A butterfly valve closes with a disc on a spindle that turns a quarter of a turn. It is short in length and light, and in the wafer form it sits between two pipe flanges. A sluice valve closes with a gate that moves across the flow, usually by turning a handwheel many times. It is longer and heavier and has more parts that wear. The rest of this page is from Zoloto’s datasheets.
What Zoloto prints for each
| Fig. | What it is | mm | PN | ISI | Operation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1078A | Wafer butterfly valve, S.G. iron disc | 200 to 600 | 1.6 | Yes | Gear operated |
| 1079A | Cast Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.0 | 50 to 600 | 1.0 | Yes | Handwheel |
| 1079B | Cast Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.6 | 50 to 300 | 1.6 | Yes | Handwheel |
| 1096 | Ductile Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.6 | 50 to 300 | 1.6 | Yes | Handwheel |
The butterfly valve 1078A is the gear-operated version for 200 to 600 mm; the lever versions 1078, 1078B and the PN 2.5 and actuated versions are in the 1078 series guide. The sluice valves are explained in the sluice valve guide. The 1079A is ISI marked up to 300 mm, with sizes above that stated as non-ISI.
Prices at common sizes
At 200 mm: the butterfly valve 1078A costs ₹21,350 as on 26 Sep 2026, the PN 1.0 sluice valve 1079A ₹51,679 as on 26 Sep 2026 and the PN 1.6 sluice valve 1079B ₹57,353 as on 26 Sep 2026. At 300 mm: 1078A ₹41,342 as on 26 Sep 2026, 1079A ₹93,774 as on 26 Sep 2026 and 1079B ₹1,08,175 as on 26 Sep 2026. The valves differ in construction, so the price gap is for budgeting. The comparison page for the sluice valves is 1079A vs 1079B.
Choosing
- Size: above 300 mm in the Zoloto range, the butterfly valves 1078A and the sluice valve 1079A are the options.
- Pressure: PN 1.0 or 1.6 for both; the butterfly valve also comes in PN 2.5.
- Space and weight: the wafer butterfly valve is the shorter, lighter choice. Check the face-to-face dimensions on the product pages.
- Operation: handwheel or gear, and actuated versions for butterfly valves only.
- Mark and standard: IS 13095 / BS EN 593 for butterfly valves and IS 14846 for sluice valves.
- Flanges: butterfly valves sit between the flanges, sluice valves are flanged to IS 1538. Tell us the flange standard and drilling.
Ask us for today’s price, and see the extras page for add-ons. For the Zoloto valves at each rating see the pressure class pages.
Questions to settle before you choose
- Headroom and weight. The sluice valve with a rising stem needs space above it, and larger sizes are heavy. Check the dimensions on the product pages.
- Operation. Zoloto’s butterfly valves can be gear, lever, pneumatic or electric. Its sluice valves are handwheel operated, and Annexure A lists extended stems and limit switches as extras: see the extras page.
- Standards your tender names. IS 13095 / BS EN 593 for the butterfly valves, IS 14846 for the sluice valves.
- ISI. The ISI mark applies to 1078, 1078A, 1078B and 1078C, and to 1079A up to 300 mm, 1079B and 1096.
Other Zoloto butterfly and sluice valves to consider. MRPs are per piece, as on 26 Sep 2026.
| Fig. | Product | Sizes (mm) | MRP per piece | HSN |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1078 | Butterfly Valve (Wafer Type) PN 1.6 with S.G Iron Disc | 40–150 | ₹3,396 to ₹8,994 | 84818030 |
| 1078B | Butterfly Valve (Wafer Type), PN 1.6 with S.S 304 Disc | 40–150 | ₹3,507 to ₹12,399 | 84818030 |
| 1079C | Cast Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.0 (Flanged) with Rising Stem | 50–300 | ₹12,405 to ₹1,16,868 | 84818030 |
What to send us
For a quotation, send the pipe size, the flange standard and drilling, the pressure class, the water temperature and the operation you want: handwheel, gear, lever, or an actuator. If the line is on a water main that the utility owns, it may also have its own approved-valve list, which Zoloto’s documents do not cover: check it before you order. We will name the Zoloto articles that match and give you the prices with their date.
Related guides
Questions
What is the main difference?
As general engineering knowledge, a butterfly valve is lighter and shorter and operates in a quarter turn, while a sluice valve is a gate valve that takes more space and more turns to operate. Zoloto's datasheets give the facts below.
Which is dearer in the Zoloto range?
It depends on the size and the version. See the prices at 200 and 300 mm in the table.
Which carries the ISI mark?
Zoloto's 1078, 1078A, 1078B and 1078C butterfly valves, and the sluice valves 1079A (up to 300 mm), 1079B and 1096, per their datasheets.
Which is better for chilled water?
Zoloto's documents do not say. Ask your designer.
Can a butterfly valve replace a sluice valve?
Only if the face-to-face length, flanges, pressure rating and operation suit. A butterfly valve is a wafer type that sits between flanges; check the dimensions with us.
Sources
- Zoloto price list dated 26.09.2026 (pages 2 to 24)
- Zoloto product catalogue, datasheets for the products named
- General engineering meaning (not from Zoloto documents) for the construction comparison
Zoloto products in this guide

Butterfly Valve (Wafer Type) PN 1.6 with S.G Iron Disc - Gear Operated
200–600 mm · 8 sizes · ISI
₹21,350 to ₹1,44,934 as on 26 Sep 2026

Cast Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.0 (Flanged)
50–600 mm · 13 sizes · ISI
₹9,946 to ₹6,63,039 as on 26 Sep 2026

Cast Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.6 (Flanged)
50–300 mm · 9 sizes · ISI
₹10,420 to ₹1,08,175 as on 26 Sep 2026

Ductile Iron Sluice Valve PN 1.6 (Flanged)
50–300 mm · 9 sizes · ISI
₹12,687 to ₹1,28,673 as on 26 Sep 2026
Prices are Zoloto's Maximum Retail Prices (MRP) per piece, as printed in the Zoloto price list dated 26 September 2026. Zoloto states that GST at 18% is included in these MRPs. Prices, sizes and availability can change without notice. Call 98490 02060 or email info@maheshvalves.com for today's price and stock before ordering.
Need a price or a quote? Call 98490 02060 or email info@maheshvalves.com.